Obituary of a Lovely Concept

Failed Innovations

For more than 3 years, every evening at 8:30 PM I used to receive an e-mail from – an online diary keeping application / portal. All I had to do was reply to it, recording my day in terms of happenings and emotions and it went to the portal as my day’s entry. It also sent me an old entry from the diary that reminded me of what I felt the same day last year or last month or last week. Sometimes I wrote at length and sometimes it was just a one liner capturing the day.

All my life I wanted to maintain a diary, but could never discipline myself to do the same. I have a diary of the days that were extreme days wither on the happiness scale or the sorrow scale, which are countable in numbers. Most usual days with their every day ups and downs were lost to sheer laziness. With Ohlife, I never missed day. Even when I was not connected, I would jot down entries for the last few days as soon as I got connected. And I have a record of all my 1000 odd days.

 I had a free account but the portal also offered a paid premium account too. In all 3+ years I never heard from the company and I actually found it quite non-intrusive and loved the portal for the same reason.

A few days back I got a mail from the founders saying they are shutting down the portal and the users can export all their entries. For premium accounts, they said they would refund the fees on a pro-rata basis. They reason for the shut down was that they could not make it commercially viable and hence can not sustain it further. When I wrote to them asking if there is we can do to help them remain live – I got no answer.

It is an example of a beautiful concept that was loved by its users going kaput. It even had the stickiness built in its model as all its users touch based with the portal at least once a day and that is a huge stickiness that most businesses would die to have. What went wrong then? Could they not rope in the right advertisers? Could they not build premium features that would tell their level 1 customers to upgrade and pay for the services – I would have happily paid a reasonable fee for this service? Could they have appealed to their users before taking the drastic decision of shutting it down? Could they have sold the portal to someone who could turn it around and make it commercially successful – in my opinion that was a very strong possibility?

A lot of entrepreneurs tell me that they are building a great product and they are not even thinking of revenues or a revenue model. This is a great example of such thinking. For any business to be successful, entrepreneur must have a clear revenue model in place – which may be tweaked based on the market response or changing conditions, but not thinking about one, because you are too busy building a product is preparing for a disaster.

Coca Cola and BT Innovate together

This Press release landed in my e-mail box few days back


Coca-Cola and BT offer free Internet access to Umtata and Nelspruit

Coca-Cola South Africa, bottling partner Coca-Cola Fortune and BT Global Services are partnering to set up WiFi on Coca-Cola machines and provide free internet access to impoverished communities in South Africa. Coca-Cola is installing the refreshment-dispensing coolers while BT is providing design and support, connectivity and internet access, as well as business training.  The pilot project has been launched in two key areas in Umtata in the Eastern Cape province and Nelspruit, in the Mpumalanga province.

“The initiative forms part of Coca-Cola’s commitment to building sustainable communities by empowering the members of these communities. We believe that by giving them access to free WiFi we will enable students and school children in the area to increase their knowledge through research while also giving entrepreneurs and small business owners in the community the opportunity to manage some of their business aspects online,” says David Visser, Chief Information Officer of Coca-Cola South Africa.

Oliver Fortuin, managing director, BT Global Services, Sub Saharan Africa, said: “We are delighted to collaborate with Coca-Cola and be involved in a project that will give underserved communities much improved access to information and education opportunities. At BT, we have a vision for a Connected Society: to help improve society globally through the power of digital connections. As well as providing access, we want to help people use technology to apply their creativity and harness the possibilities of today’s connected world.”

The project provides WiFi connectivity for community members of Nelspruit and Umtata. The sites were strategically chosen for their accessibility, so as to maximise usage of technology by the locals. The first site is Sasol Integrated Energy Centre (SIEC) in Qunu, Umtata. This is a popular spot for locals and is in close proximity to a taxi rank, attracting large numbers of people. Furthermore SIEC is run by a predominantly women run co-operative which will benefit from the increased flow of people. The second site is located at Thokozane Fast Food situated in Bushbuckridge, Mpumalanga.

Both outlets are in the vicinity of shopping centres and schools, allowing members of the communities to combine their day-to-day activities with the opportunity to access the internet for business and educational purposes. Internet access is offered for free via WiFi, without any purchase requirement of any kind and is accessible for the duration of the time spent at the outlets.

Coca-Cola South Africa, Coca-Cola Fortune and BT Global Services aim to grow the project and install WiFi coolers in various parts of South Africa to help support and grow sustainable communities.


I thought this can be a beautiful example of intersectional innovation as well as collaborative innovation. Intersection – because two companies from two very different domains thought of a solution that lies at the intersection of their strengths. Coca-Cola’s strength lies in its strong distribution network for which their machines are the last nodal points. BT of course is telecom major and they collaborated to marry their strengths to serve a communities that are otherwise isolated due to unavailability of Internet.

Integrated Travel Options

Travel involves many modes of transport. While you may use airlines to go from your city to another – but then to reach the airport and from the airport you need either a tax, or a bus or a metro train or may be any other mode of local transportation. Put together all modes of transport available provide innumerable combinations from which we can choose. Often the criteria to choose involve the time available to us or the cost involved.

A recently launched website in Europe called attempts to provide an integrated view of multiple modes of transport available. As of now it is available for three countries UK, Germany and Spain. Since its launch in late May 2013, this Berlin-based company has offered a simple and complete overview of train, bus, and plane connections. Users can easily compare and combine all travel options, finding the fastest and cheapest connections. Travellers can search to and from any location in Europe, including small towns and villages, eliminating the need to visit numerous websites to piece together an entire journey. To add to the tool’s capabilities, all air searches automatically display transportation costs to and from the airport, as well as check-in and waiting times, enabling easy comparison with train and bus alternatives.

Key innovation of GoEuro is that multiple modes of travel are searched, compared, combined, and displayed to the user, taking into account the whole journey and also making searches to and from smaller places, villages and sites of interest (Stonehenge for example) possible. In the CEO Naren Shaam’s words, “there are significant complexities involved in building a search platform from the ground up, which seamlessly integrates massive amounts of data from every airline, rail and bus operator and car rental firm across Europe.” It already features 150 airports, 12,900 rail, and 8,500 bus stations, and serving almost 23,000 unique locations in the UK, Spain and Germany. The company has signed a number of high-profile and mutually successful agreements with partners such as National Express in the UK and Renfe in Spain.  GoEuro’s business model is simple. It does not charge its users to use the search tool, and the prices found on the site reflect the price on the partners’ (transport providers’) websites. Whenever a purchase is made from GoEuro traffic, the providers are sent cookies. In return, they give GoEuro cake. In different terms, GoEuro earns a commission based on the purchase.

In India MakeMyTrip has a similar offering by the name Route Planner. Read more about it in the book The Mouse Charmers

Textile Industry of Bangladesh

This NPR post called Nixon And Kimchi: How The Garment Industry Came To Bangladesh gives the history of garment business as its set its foot in Bangladesh, a country that is now a major exporter of garments. Not much has been written about this industry. I did not know that the roots of this industry lie in the quota system that the west has put in place for imports from individual countries that were exporting garments in 1970s. This created a need for setting shops in new countries for many established exporters and one of them happened to be Daewoo of Korea. At the same time a Bangaladeshi entrepreneur was looking for avenues to set up business to get out of poverty. This led to him putting together a team of workers to take to Korea for training. Both the native and the visiting teams went through their cultural challenges, they learnt to live and work with each other and the result is a burgeoning garments industry in a young developing country.

To me this story sounded something Malcolm Gladwell would love to analyze and present. 3-4 disjointed factors coming together and leading to the creation of an industry that not only provides livelihoods to many but also becomes the identity of a new born nation. It is also a good example of policy makers that tells them the far reaching impacts of the policies they make for themselves primarily but may have far reaching impact. It talks about the pioneers who step out of the comfort zone and go out to explore the unknown world. They may fail at times but they are more likely to hit gold as they are more prepared for it.

Businesses and individuals can learn a lot from this story.

Business of Sports

FICCI Sports

We tend to look at sports as just that a sport. But do we realize there is a burgeoning industry in India around sports and many opportunities to be explored. There are lots of activities happening around couple of sports that are minting money, and I know Cricket and to an extent Tennis come to mind. What about so many other sports? What about so many potential sports persons? What about talent hunting and talent grooming just like the way it is done for other professions? What about sports event management? What about sports related content? What about building communities more often called clubs around sports and running them? What about building infrastructure for sports in non-metros? What about creating centers of excellence for every possible sport in country? Think of the cascading impact it would have on entertainment industry, manufacturing industry and fitness industry? Think of the wellness quotient that is bound to go up. Think about the potential it holds for tourism industry.

Haryana is a state that we know only for its agriculture, but this is one state that has put its focus on sports. I read through its sports policy and their focus on making each district a center of excellence in one sport. It talks about systematic identification of talent in schools, followed by a planned nurturing of talent that includes providing right training and nutrition, providing ample opportunities for them to showcase their talent and providing employment to sportspersons who excel in their field. The result is their for us to see. State is already producing medal winners in boxing and wrestling in international events including Olympics. The representation of state in international teams is very high compared to its population percentage in the country. It is not a mere co-incidence that all award winning boxers come from a small town called Bhiwani. If you look their backgrounds, none of them come from affluent backgrounds that could afford training or even the kind of food requirements these professionals have. It is because Bhiwani happens to be Boxing CoE for state of Haryana and these sportsmen are a result of the policy implementation by the state. I am keeping my fingers crossed for the rest of the sports as well.

Haryana has a round the year sports calendar that has sports events right from block level to national levels that is publicly published encouraging participation. Play for India initiatives encourages every student to take up a sport with the aim to represent India in that field. Sports infrastructure has been built with sports nurseries and stadiums at districts and blocks. Apart from the government machinery, they are actively engaging school staff, parents and local bodies like panchayats to take up this cause and own it.  Incentives for the achievers and performers are defined. A few star performers today inspire many more to take up sports as a profession.

This is an area that requires huge public private partnership to tap the huge potential that the sports hold for the youth of the country as a passion, profession and as an industry with a supporting eco-system.

Trade organization FICCI organized TURF 2013 – a Global Sports Summit that also hosts India Sports Awards in New Delhi. It is India’s largest convention on business of sports. You can submit your research papers or business ideas around Sports to them. Their contact is  [email protected] T:+91-11-2348-7283/561

Thanks to, the online media partner for FICCI’s TURF 2013 for inviting me to be apart of the LIVE Blogging @TURF 2013 experience.

In Flight Innovations

Inflight entertainment

Last month I flew Malaysian Airlines from Hyderabad to KL and back. I also took domestic flights to fly back and forth between Kuala Lumpur and Terengganu. On my onward flight i.e. Hyd- KL flight, I was fiddling with the in-flight entertainment system, and it offered all that we expect like films in multiple languages, various genres of music shopping opportunities and the mandatory flight information. What was new though was a module on books, that means the books can be read on the panel. Incidentally they had only one book at the moment, but I am sure going forward they can have a small library of books to choose from. Most people carry books with them to read in flights and as much as we love books, they do weigh a lot. There is a small percentage of population that carries its e-book readers but most do not. As an avid reader,  I am looking forward to these libraries on-board. To get all the copyright free books can be first step in stocking these libraries. From a business perspective this can also be a tool for publishers to let the potential readers read a sample chapter and give them an option to buy if they like it.

Malaysian airlines is also one of the few airlines that connects its home country to various Indian cities like Bangalore, Chennai, Hyderabad besides the two big cities Delhi & Mumbai.  This makes sense as all the three south Indian cities are actually physically closer to Malaysia and hence can have direct short flights operating between them. Kuala lumpur also acts as a hub for Indians flying to various cities of Australia.

At KLIA , we also got to enjoy the hospitality at the Golden Lounge of Malaysian Airlines that overlooks the open space with planes parked all over. I was happy to find enough vegetarian food, good Wi-Fi connection and comfortable seating to finish off my pending e-mails. They also had a few tablets and PCs that could be used in case you are not carrying your own computer. A thoughtful feature.

Innovation: Bucket from Used Tyres

Rural Innovations

Bucket made from used tyres…Image Courtesy: Hemant Abhyankar


I was in Jhabua, MP to attend a tribal festival and at that fair I saw various small innovations, or rather ways of using stuff that lives the principle of re-cycle, re-use and reduce.

This bucket was one of the things made from used tyres, that are usually discarded and are hardly considered useful for anything else. There were slippers and other footwear also made from the same rubber, and people were using them as regular items.

Is this not what we need to imbibe in our lifestyles?

This is a picture of